#onepiece #anime #manga #onepiecemanga #onepieceanime
FAIR-USE COPYRIGHT DISCLAIMER:
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
source
Am I the only one that thought the Zeff backstory was better in the anime?
I dont know, the thought of him losing his leg specifically to save Sanji just gives me a “I see something in this kid” vibe to it that I really like.
Also considering that both Sanji and Zeff experience extreme starvation is something that ties them together is a bit watered down if Zeff just succumbed to the hunger and ate his own limb. Having him starving the WHOLE time they were stranded made the story feel more impactful to me rather than him eating his own leg.
I dunno man I liked the anime version more, one of the few cases I did like the censorship LMAO
live action did this more accurate than the anime lol
Fun fact, this is only a problem in the 4kids version. In the normal version, he does cut off his leg and eat it.
He ate his leg in the live action
Everyday im more glad that i dont have the time to watch the one piece anime, and can just read the manga in peace.
The all blue mattered that much to zeff too right? He fucking shanksed it
I didn't even know. That's why the live action did that …
Ngl the first time i saw the story, my ADHD brain forgot about the added censorship of him taking his leg underwater and i naturally assumed he ate his foot.
So i had always imagined the manga version without reading it
Oda is so precious. In the screenshot he told people to send fan letters and show love to the toei animators so it could cheer them up
Why did I assume he just ate his leg even though I’ve only seen the anime💀
Scientifically you lose more calories eating your leg, than keeping it and letting your body absorb nutrients from it. But i likenthe symbolism of him losing his leg to save sanji, but either way both versions made a great sacrifice
Maybe this is a hot take, but I HATE the original version of this scene, and think the anime actually fixed it.
(Tl;dr: The human body is better at "eating itself" than actually eating itself)
The human body already has a mechanism for sustaining itself when it's starving. It's called "autophagy", and it's a more efficient way of metabolizing the body for energy than digestion. Zeff had to contend with excruciating pain, blood loss, and possibly shock just to get less out of that leg than he would have if he'd just sat there.
The anime even had Zeff making a sacrifice for Sanji! He only got caught in the wreckage that forced him to cut off his leg because he was trying to save Sanji.
I love how this guy always has Roger's theme playing in the background
Knowing Zeff he’d find a way to make that precious yummy yummy leg meat both last and be delicious. That’s the kind of man who trained Sanji
I don't hate this one. The way Zeff lost his leg in the anime was just as hardcore and so was going hungry the whole time.
I find both versions equally powerful, because you just KNOW zeff expected a lot worse to happen (like DROWNING) when he dove overboard
Bro was fully prepared to die the entire time for that little kid he just met
Also the anchor part was CRAZY
Live action fixed it
Kind of glad because I was like 9-10 when I first watched one piece (I know, I was young) and seeing that would’ve left me shook
This seems to imply that Zeff didn't give all the food to Sanji in the anime, but I recall him doing that.
Also, he got stuck in underwater debris while trying to rescue Sanji from drowning, so all the major story beats still happen: Zeff sacrifices his leg and gives up the food he needs to make sure a child is safe.
I'm not going to lie watching these videos had made me come back to one piece.
It doesnt make sense for zeff to chop a leg before an arm tho u gotta admit.
Just realized the island looks like a chef's hat
So glad the live action did this scene service
I was so surprised when they DID include it in the Live Action. 😊
In the new anime adaptation I hope they restore this scene.
Imagine how it must have felt to have a father figure like this while growing up with Judge
i like that they kept it in the live action, made sanji telling his back story much more emocional
I don't ever recall this???
Oh it was in the live action, and it was really well done
Maybe in the anime remake they’ll do Zeff justice
i’m glad the show in netflix did it justice
I’m a villain not a monster ahh scene
I have to disagree, because no matter the hunger, breaking and losing a limb will always be much worse than what you get from eating it.
Human meat is not good for humans, let alone raw. Although more shocking, the scene is dumb.
Weird. I fully thought that he ate it in the anime. What i saw in the show was that he injured it, so it had to be amputated, and then he used it for food.
I understand why they would cut that but it really takes away from the themes. Sanji being so dedicated to feeding everyone is more hard-hitting when you consider eating his own leg for him
Yeah in anime its doesn't make sense like zeff who have strongest legs can't take off some debris in water? 😂
i swear in the og anime it was zeff eating his leg ….
Live action corrected this😢
No no no no no its as powerfull and less grafic because he did muteleted him self to save sanji in both versions so its genius because its less grafic but not less powerfull
Wait wait, the anime isn't supposed to imply this? I swear to god I always thought it was implied he ate his leg. Otherwise Sanji's reaction to seeing he's missing a leg makes little sense
In reality eating your own leg would be a bad idea, as your body will need lot of energy to recover from this, more than what you'll gain by eating the leg.
But it's one piece, no need to be "scientifically right", and yeah when you read this part it's a shock ! And we feel how Sanji feels toward his mentor, despite him faking disrespect.
I enjoy both versions for two different reasons, the manga is great because as horrible as it was for him to experience it was a practical reason and I like the anime because that was zeff basically declaring he'd rather die just to give sanji a chance at living
And the live action actually stayed accurate, that was amazing
They'll censor that but "nothing happened" is perfectly natural. They banned the crossdressing pokemon episode but Law said "hold my fruit" on Punk Hazard. One piece anime should 100% never be censored.
It's been recently proven that cutting off a limb to be eaten is actually a net loss in energy than it is a gain. The shock your body goes through upon having a limb forcefully removed causes it to burn more energy than you'd get by eating said limb.
I'm 90% sure Oda had no idea about this when writing the sequence to it makes sense so I don't really think he's dumb for writing it or anything, but when you look at it from this point of view the anime makes more sense. In both instances Zeff gave up a limb just to save Sanji, a boy he had literally just met. It's just in one sequence he loses his limb due to a situation outside of his control and the other is due to him making a choice that actually harms himself more than helps.