44 thoughts on “GMFB | "Mahomes or Josh Allen – Who's best QB of AFC" – Peter Schrager drops trump bomb AFC Division”
I was so happy to get Josh Allen I knew about the inaccuratcy problem but he was so tough and that's what we needed in Buffalo. Happy to say I was right.
As a Chiefs fan I wanted to move up for McCaffrey. When we took the the 10 spot Mahomes was definitely my top choice for QB. He was a more gifted QB than Watsons and Turbisky just raw and who is better than Andy developing raw talent.
Allen is by far the better quarterback for sure. This season will go a long way in exposing Mahomes. The truth of the matter is KC's entire offensive system was based on Mahomes being able to dance behind the pocket for over 5 seconds and waiting till that devastating speed to eventually break down secondaries league wide. Linebackers were not going to blitz in fear of leaving dbs alone to cover Hill which gave Mahomes even more time to dance behiind the pocket. It was essentially a no win situation for defenses. The one defense in the entire NFL that could get home with 4 guys..Tampa.. proved my theory in the Super Bowl when they put the clamp on Mahomes. Hill is what made their offense tick. It wasn't Mahomes. Now Mahomes gonna have to prove this year he can do it with average WR's and quite frankly, I don't see it. He can still improvise like the best of him however waiting for Juju and company to gain seperation not gonna work. Defenses will be way more aggressive this year. As far as Allen goes, we saw what magic he could unleash sitting in the pocket throwing darts to mid round picks like Gabe Davis. He didn't even need Diggs as he was a no show. It's a proven fact, the hardest thing in the NFL to stop is an elite pocket passing QB. That will never die out. This is why Allen is essentially better. Mahomes is a system QB while Josh Allen is the system
A lifelong bills fan who fell in love with Josh Allen in march when I put on the tape. I told all my friends, family and people who cared to listen that they had to get him in a Bills jersey. Hearing “Josh” and not knowing if it was Rosen or Allen was the longest second of my life. Feel bad Rosen got the raw deal he did but couldn’t be happier Josh Allen is a bill!
Not saying he can’t but until Allen wins an mvp, a Super Bowl takes him to another SB and wins SB mvp , throws for 5000 yards and 50 TDS I don’t think their is a conversation
Most of the media, scouts, draft gurus were Allen haters, before the draft, this wasn't just Bills fans. They should be more ashamed, they're paid to know. Only guys that knew were the Bills – Beane/McDermott and Mel Kiper.
bills fans are the most bandwagon hillbilly fans in the league ask them without looking it up name a QB besides Josh Allen or oj simpson that played for the bills, there weren't many bills fans when the pats owned them for 20 years😂😂😂
They're both phenomenal QBs. I'm taking Mahomes though. He's never had a Top 10 defense and he's, at least, made the conference championship every season as a starter.
Those tweets about picking Rosen over Allen aged poorly. It went basically the exact opposite of how they thought it would, Allen has become one of the best in the league and Rosen has pretty much flamed out and been on multiple different teams🤣. I'm so happy we picked Allen
I’m an Allen fan from buffalo,Mahomes is phenomenal,but he had 900 more yards after the catch last year over Allen..that says a lot on who’s catching the ball for both teams,but I’ll take Allen because he hasn’t hit his peak yet,and he needs more speed at the receiver position..just my 2 cents
I’m A HUGEEEEEE KC FAN!!!!!!! And that will NEVER change!!!!! But I will NEVER sit there and say Allen sucks because he’s a damn good QB.. I feel I’m gonna have a heart attack when we play the Bills every time!!!!!!!!
All I know is one of if not the best arm good to great runner makes all kinds of extra times with his feet can run over guys jump over guys and had the best QBR in post season history I’ll take that guy because no one has all those traits not even close get him a proper Oline and he’s winning a few Super Bowls soon
Just goes to show you how hateful people are, and how narcissism reigns supreme in soc. Media. If these fools were asked now what they meant by those tweets then, listen to their lies now. Go BILLS!
I completely agree Watson is better than Mahomes. Mahomes was put into one of three best situations an NFL quarterback had ever began his career in. I'm not sure if the chiefs would have ever lost a game if they took Watson. Mahomes is HIGHLY OVERRATED…
I was so happy to get Josh Allen
I knew about the inaccuratcy problem but he was so tough and that's what we needed in Buffalo.
Happy to say I was right.
Allen. Had the chiefs beat twice last year. Not Allen's fault for the defenses lapse at 13 seconds left
As a Chiefs fan I wanted to move up for McCaffrey. When we took the the 10 spot Mahomes was definitely my top choice for QB. He was a more gifted QB than Watsons and Turbisky just raw and who is better than Andy developing raw talent.
I m huge buffalo fan
Still mahomes very very slim margin but Allen will surpass him in 2022 -2023 mvp and superbowl champion 🏆
The fact Mahomes and Allen didn’t both go #1 means the pros aren’t that great at picking talent either 😂
City of good neighbors* Philly is brotherly love
Who have a ring lmao 🤣
Allen is by far the better quarterback for sure. This season will go a long way in exposing Mahomes. The truth of the matter is KC's entire offensive system was based on Mahomes being able to dance behind the pocket for over 5 seconds and waiting till that devastating speed to eventually break down secondaries league wide. Linebackers were not going to blitz in fear of leaving dbs alone to cover Hill which gave Mahomes even more time to dance behiind the pocket. It was essentially a no win situation for defenses. The one defense in the entire NFL that could get home with 4 guys..Tampa.. proved my theory in the Super Bowl when they put the clamp on Mahomes. Hill is what made their offense tick. It wasn't Mahomes. Now Mahomes gonna have to prove this year he can do it with average WR's and quite frankly, I don't see it. He can still improvise like the best of him however waiting for Juju and company to gain seperation not gonna work. Defenses will be way more aggressive this year. As far as Allen goes, we saw what magic he could unleash sitting in the pocket throwing darts to mid round picks like Gabe Davis. He didn't even need Diggs as he was a no show. It's a proven fact, the hardest thing in the NFL to stop is an elite pocket passing QB. That will never die out. This is why Allen is essentially better. Mahomes is a system QB while Josh Allen is the system
Josh Allen best qb in the league
A lifelong bills fan who fell in love with Josh Allen in march when I put on the tape. I told all my friends, family and people who cared to listen that they had to get him in a Bills jersey. Hearing “Josh” and not knowing if it was Rosen or Allen was the longest second of my life. Feel bad Rosen got the raw deal he did but couldn’t be happier Josh Allen is a bill!
So your content is to trash fans. Keep doing that your rating will explode.
WHY IS THIS A QUESTION?
Josh Allen is with out a doubt and he’s just going to get better
Carr
Not even gonna lie didn't know who Josh Allen was but the world knows now
Josh Allen ..is the best player..in all sports…
Not saying he can’t but until Allen wins an mvp, a Super Bowl takes him to another SB and wins SB mvp , throws for 5000 yards and 50 TDS I don’t think their is a conversation
Most of the media, scouts, draft gurus were Allen haters, before the draft, this wasn't just Bills fans. They should be more ashamed, they're paid to know. Only guys that knew were the Bills – Beane/McDermott and Mel Kiper.
Click bait lol
Neither. Justin Herbert.
Russel Wilson
Mahomes is overrated…his security blanket is gone…so are the chiefs
Neither is the best. You could give these four equal teams and coaches:
Allen
Watson
Mahomes
Russ
I would take Watson and Russ over Allen and Mahomes. Leaving out DWat’s current legal troubles, I think he handles pressure better than Mahomes.
Russ has been handcuffed and anchored by Pete Carroll and has had to play without the offensive support that Mahomes and Allen gave enjoyed.
If KC had drafted DWat instead of Mahomes they would already have three Lombardis.
I hated the Josh Allen pick..I was pissed.. NEVER have I been so happy to be so completely wrong.
Allen without a doubt his talent is unmatched by any qb in the league
bills fans are the most bandwagon hillbilly fans in the league ask them without looking it up name a QB besides Josh Allen or oj simpson that played for the bills, there weren't many bills fans when the pats owned them for 20 years😂😂😂
The "professionals" don't always get it right either.
Hey that guy wasn’t too wrong yeah chase is a beast but they did need an offensive lineman
They're both phenomenal QBs. I'm taking Mahomes though. He's never had a Top 10 defense and he's, at least, made the conference championship every season as a starter.
Mahomes. He will have Chiefs in contention every year if his career.
We wanted Chosen Rosen and instead we got Wrong Josh. And that's why we let the professionals make the picks
Allen 🏋🏻
Those tweets about picking Rosen over Allen aged poorly. It went basically the exact opposite of how they thought it would, Allen has become one of the best in the league and Rosen has pretty much flamed out and been on multiple different teams🤣. I'm so happy we picked Allen
Burrow.
I’m an Allen fan from buffalo,Mahomes is phenomenal,but he had 900 more yards after the catch last year over Allen..that says a lot on who’s catching the ball for both teams,but I’ll take Allen because he hasn’t hit his peak yet,and he needs more speed at the receiver position..just my 2 cents
ALLEN
GO BILLS
Coming from a Bills fan I’d be equally happy with either quarterback
I’m A HUGEEEEEE KC FAN!!!!!!! And that will NEVER change!!!!! But I will NEVER sit there and say Allen sucks because he’s a damn good QB.. I feel I’m gonna have a heart attack when we play the Bills every time!!!!!!!!
No disrespect to allen.but its Mahomet of course
All I know is one of if not the best arm good to great runner makes all kinds of extra times with his feet can run over guys jump over guys and had the best QBR in post season history I’ll take that guy because no one has all those traits not even close get him a proper Oline and he’s winning a few Super Bowls soon
Just goes to show you how hateful people are, and how narcissism reigns supreme in soc. Media. If these fools were asked now what they meant by those tweets then, listen to their lies now. Go BILLS!
I completely agree Watson is better than Mahomes. Mahomes was put into one of three best situations an NFL quarterback had ever began his career in. I'm not sure if the chiefs would have ever lost a game if they took Watson. Mahomes is HIGHLY OVERRATED…
Neither one. ON THE FIELD, I like Russ, DWat, Burrow, and Herbert better than both.
At least there’s no photo of Mahomes’s woman with her mouth wide open.