Are we really so different from the farm animals we eat? Philosophical thought experiments elucidate this question, bringing together the differing perspectives of philosophers and researchers, along with entertaining animations.
Peter Singer, Professor of Ethics at Princeton University, is seen as the philosophical father of the contemporary animal rights movement. Based on the philosophy of utilitarianism, the doctrine that sees the basis of moral behavior in the utilitarian, he convincingly explains why we need to consider the interests and feelings of animals in our views on meat consumption just as much as those of other humans.
But what do animals really feel? Sara Hintze is an animal welfare researcher at the University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences in Vienna. She studies the emotions of farm animals. Touching footage from her lab shows young fattening pigs displaying astonishingly human-like behavior in psychological experiments.
How do we know that animals feel, but that plants do not? Evolutionary biologist Jon Mallatt is concerned with precisely this boundary between the conscious and the unconscious world. He takes viewers on a journey 500 million years back in time, and explains why animals began to develop the first feelings.
Finally, we hear from Dan Shahar, one of the few philosophers to present an ethical defense of the consumption of meat. His arguments donโt gloss over the realities of livestock farming, but pose the question: what moral demands do we want to make on ourselves?
โThe Great Meat Debateโ (5-part documentary series):
Part 1: Factory farming, animal welfare and the future of modern agriculture โ https://youtu.be/6VOqNVt_cmM
Part 2: Do we need to eat meat? โ https://youtu.be/hKs7fidCWMA
Part 3: Ethics and meat consumption โ https://youtu.be/eF9sqj6CfG4
Part 4: The world of meat substitutes โ [Coming soon]
Part 5: A vegan lifestyle: Is it the future? โ [Coming soon]
#documentary #dwdocumentary #meat
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
โฎ DW Documentary (English): https://www.youtube.com/dwdocumentary
โฎ DW Documental (Spanish): https://www.youtube.com/dwdocumental
โฎ DW Documentary ูุซุงุฆููุฉ ุฏู ุฏุจููู (Arabic): https://www.youtube.com/dwdocarabia
โฎ DW Doku (German): https://www.youtube.com/dwdoku
โฎ DW Documentary เคนเคฟเคจเฅเคฆเฅ (Hindi): https://www.youtube.com/dwdochindi
For more visit: http://www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/dwdocumentary/
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: https://p.dw.com/p/MF1G
source
Dear viewers, we would like to apologize for the insert mistake @ 26:51 and any issues it may have caused. The insert should read: Dan Shahar, Author of "Why It's OK to Eat Meat".
Brilliant documentary!!! Eagerly waiting for the next one ๐
I eat meat and doubt that I will ever be a vegetarian, however…There is another point that should be made here: Ethics towards the environment (knowing that meat production requires intensive use of land, water and natural resources in general). Thank you DW for your great docs. Cheers!
I was unable to quit smoking since a long time. 6 months ago I stopped consuming meat. It has been 2 months since i smoked my last cigarette. I have never felt so satisfied before. Self control is the key.
๐
ohhhhhh mannnn, here we go again. what has meat done to dw. no matter what we gonna keep eating meat till thy Kingdom come even at the cost of climate change.
next y'all should give animals social security and welfare too then we gonna treat them otherwise untill then, they are nothing but food for me and my fellow meat eaters.
Thanks for the content. I'm omnivore and I'm going to the graveyard as a meat eater (unless it's too expensive, I don't buy high cost food). But I consider valid to think and question why we do, say and eat things in our life as defender of the critical sense.
Nowadays I wouldn't force my kids to eat meat if they don't desire , mch less censor them being presented to vegetarianism/veganism content. I believe the new generations that are coming in stable countries will be way more aware of their consuming when it comes to this specific subject. I wish you all a healthy life
Great documentary, I'm waiting the second part
24:50 This is just wrong. All currently extant species are arguably equally 'successful' or good at escaping predators. Why would a bee, who demonstrably plays with objects for fun, not have emotions like some vertebrate? What do we know about the inner world of cephalopods?
More basic than that: why should we care about minimizing bad emotions?
I'm not going to lie, I'm eating a t bone steak right now
wouldn't want it to go to waste, would we
DW stop trying, we are not going to eat ze bugs.
I'm from Colombia, I live in the countryside. I can say here almost no one is vegetarian, I pray someday I become the first one, or the last; it doesn't matter. Just not participate in the suffering of any animal with the ability to feel pain
There's chain reaction for a change. I was the first vegetarian in my family at the age of 15, then my aunt became vegetarian, then my father, a brother, a sister, a causin sister, one of my niece and list is coming gradually. Nobody forced them to become but they got inspired and their compassion woke up.
Edit : only through understanding other's suffering, altruism, moral ethic and compassion can bring vegan or vegetarianism into world. 5% do that due to health consciousness.
Track ID for 11:50, kindly. Unfortunately can't identify it using normal methods.
Why should I care what animals feel ๐คทโโ๏ธ๐คทโโ๏ธ๐คทโโ๏ธ? Do animals know how I feel after eating them ? No !
"As long as there are slaughter houses there will always be battlefields."
–Leo Tolstoy
All of this doc got me quite hungry…. let's go and eat some red meat ! The rest of you that want to eat grains and vegetables go ahead and leave us alone with our #1 food animal protein with animal fat!
Socrates fight to bring us, a society where we can analyze and build something better for all of us. Unfortunately, sophism continues to win this battle. The documentary was excellent and obvious to me the first minutes explain all. I suggest everyone who cares about animals reflect in truth. Who you are? Looks like simple questions, but if your pursuit the truth to answer, and analyze the words that you choose to explain, you will see that can be deeper, and not superficial as a sophist society teach you to be.
You guys really did that last guy (Dan Shahar) dirty by attempting to draw parallels between his reasoning and that extreme paedophile example. Classic Straw man fallacy
But it is animals that use us for food, shelter, reproduction, disease treatment etc. Their death which is eventual for all species is just the price they have to pay. I mean animal numbers would decrease substantially if we all became vegetarians. What if the whole system we have is just an evolutionary response for survival of both animal and human species. What if animal responses such as fattening, flavorful meat and fast growth are mechanisms to make each species more attractive to humans hence giving them a higher chance of survival and continuity. Everyone should be able to look at the issue from this perspective.
This is amazing!!! Great content. ๐๐ฑ๐
last guy is an idiot but overall good documentary
I do not oppose the idea of vegetarians, but animals do not have a mind, and when they give birth, they give birth to many twins from 4-7, mercy and provision from God for us I will be with you if you find another job for her on earth The topic speaks of its equality, and it is animals that grow up if we do not slaughter them, they grow up and die
But Human grows up to develop the land and build it. Development takes place with Human, but animals do not If you hit one of the animals that we eat for another way, a benefit other than this, another goal, the issue will be completely different. And it's true we have to protect our animals โคโ๐ฉน
29:00 this dude is bending over backwards to justify something he knows is morally reprehensible and environmentally disastrous just because he enjoys it.
nothing, they feel nothing and we love eating meat. You can eat your crickets if you prefer. I'll eat what people have been eating for thousands of years. And that's OK!
VERY INTERESTING LOVE THIS WORK I TOO ALWAYS STRUGGLING WITH THESE QUESTIONS THAN FOR DEEPENING UNDERSTANDING
GREAT WORK I LISTENING EACH & EVERY WORD OF THIS DOCUMENTRY
Thanks to past trauma I get pleasure in seeing living beings suffer.
First step would be to ban killing of mammals.
Then we may move to birds and then to fish
What if the tomato and onion think about the same when we try to eat them.. I am vegetarian but some how the logic does not fit together. So are we grouping what does not have nervous system does not have emotion like the way we use to and therefore it is okay to eat those because we do not understand their system
Great job guys! Your perspective really makes me think.
Embrace your self ! bill gates artificial synthetic meat is coming !
What a load of bullshit๐๐๐. I have lived in a farm my whole life and pigs can be just as smart as a dog. Doesnโt change the fact they taste good.
Putting ethics aside, what about the long term effect on the environment which I beleive we are feeling now already. There is no longer balance. We are our own worst enemies.
Professor Gary Iโm having a vegan meal while watching the documentary โ๏ธ๐ #ethics #morallysuperior
Really makes the viewer think ๐๐๐
Great thought-provoking documentary ๐.
I am glad the series is not over. This film ends on the matter of 'taste' – and this is so huge a point that surely the next program will be looking at 'alternative proteins' – the growing investment into the development of lab-grown meat, harming no animal at all. I envisage a world where there are two markets for meat – one which grants animals an outdoor life, as close to their natural beings as possible, for as long as possible, and a very humane slaughter process. That meat will cost its true price. It will not be cheap. And the other market will be lab-grown meat which tastes as near as damn it as good as natural meat but is much cheaper. It will not be the same as what I call 'humane meat' – the real thing – but it will be very acceptable for many of us to have that special taste which a vegetarian diet just cannot provide. It's great to be able to mix meat and veg!
Steak and chips is amazing
What is the tough process around a tiger eating a gazelle then? Try telling that not to inflict pain according to your logic
I like the idea about the aliens farming us ๐คฃ
Excellent work DW!!!
26:05 made me so sad
women..they want men to treat them right but a lower being in the hierarchy and tables are turned.๐ฎ๐ฎ๐ฎ๐ฎ. Hypocrisy. ๐น๐น๐น๐น
youtube ๐๐๐ the content and awareness here. woooohh…๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ
26:40 this man is joke. living on million dollar house and making law for poor animals ๐ ๐ . When politician takes away tax. same people will cry like a baby.โน๏ธโน๏ธ
A nonsence hiding his face behind mask