The Mediocre Masterpiece Of IDW Sonic The Hedgehog: The 5 Year Retrospective (IDW Sonic Video Essay)



After the subsequent end of Archie Comics’ Sonic The Hedgehog series, the torch would be passed to a publisher with 3 letters to its name, and with almost 6 years under their belt, did they ultimately succeed in bringing Sonic back to the comic book pages yet again? Welcome ladies and gentlemen to the (as of now) complete retrospective of IDW Comics Sonic The Hedgehog!

Chapters
0:44 Introduction
2:56 Fallout (Issues 1-4)
4:33 The Fate Of Dr.Eggman (Issues 5-6)
6:30 The Battle For Angel Island Prologue (Issues 7-8)
8:16 The Battle For Angel Island (Issues 9-11)
10:22 The Battle For Angel island Epilogue (Issue 12)
12:04 2018 Overview
13:04 The Metal Virus Prologue (Issues 13-14)
14:25 The 2019 Annual
17:25 The Metal Virus Part One (Issues 15-23)
21:58 Tangle & Whisper
24:12 The Metal Virus Part One (Issue 24)
25:32 2019 Overview
26:37 The Metal Virus Part Two (Issues 25-29)
29:43 The 2020 Annual
33:27 The Metal Virus Part Two (Issues 30-32)
35:51 Chao Races & Badnick Bases (Issue 33)/Bad Guys
38:18 Chao Races & Badnick Bases (Issues 34-36)
41:08 2020 Overview
42:22 Test Run (Issues 37-40)
44:35 Zeti Hunt ft.@Lbroreal (Issues 41-42)
46:07 Sonic’s 30th Anniversary Special
50:17 Zeti Hunt (Issues 43-44)
52:32 FCBD 2021
53:17 Trial By Fire (Issues 45-47)
55:01 Imposter Syndrome (Issue 1)
56:28 2021 Overview
57:32 Imposter Syndrome (Issues 2-4)
59:33 Battle For The Empire Prologue (Issues 48-49)
1:00:40 Sonic The Hedgehog 2 Movie Prequil
1:03:32 FCBD 2022
1:04:25 Battle For The Empire/Overpowered (Issues 50-53)
1:09:36 The 2022 Annual
1:13:07 Scrapnick Island
1:15:54 Tails’ 30th Anniversary Special
1:17:25 Overpowered (Issues 54-56)
1:20:01 2022 Overview
1:20:43 The Current State Of The Comic
1:26:07 Conclusion

Music Used
One Sweet Brutal Evening – GenesisKeys
SGSG – GenesisKeys
Know The Place (Alt. Mix) – GenesisKeys
Something Wonderful – Contra Hard Corps.
Spin On The Bridge – Streets Of Rage 2
Boss Theme – TMNT: Turtles In Time
Theme Of Cyclops – X-Men: Mutant Apocalypse
Open World Theme 3 – Ultimate Spider-Man
Metal Cavern – Super Smash Bros.
X-Ages – Alien Soldier
Ichor – GenesisKeys
Thematikos – GenesisKeys
Boss Theme – Streets Of Rage 3
Beats In My Head (Elena’s Theme) – Street Fighter 3: Third Strike
Toxic Dump/Genetics Lab (Part 3) – The Ooze
Already Rich – Yeat
Waste Plant (Part 3) – The Ooze
Defeat Pinky Roader-Gunstar Heroes
Tomboy (Elena’s Theme)-Street Fighter 3: 2nd Impact
Track 19 (Final Boss) – Comix Zone
Drumsone (alt. mix) – GenesisKeys
Act Cadenza Promo Remix – GenesisKeys
Pursuit Theme 3 – Need For Speed: Most Wanted
Jazz Castle – Jazz Jackrabbit 2
Pursuit Theme 2 – Need For Speed: Most Wanted
Moon – Streets Of Rage 3
Crystal Snail – Mega Man X2
Violent Breathing – Streets Of Rage
Buster – GenesisKeys
Images(Athena) – GenesisKeys
Theme Of Shuma-Gorath – Marvel VS. Capcom 3: Fate Of Two Worlds
Team Galactic Battle (SSBB Remix) – Pokémon Diamond/Pearl
Runner/AD2025 – Alien Soldier
Inventory – Decap Attack
Theme of Smash Daisaku – Gunstar Heroes
Dudley’s Theme – Street Fighter 3: 3rd Strike
Flame Stag – Mega Man X2
The Real Menace – GenesisKeys
the edge is not real – GenesisKeys
Boss Battle 1 – Streets Of Rage
Yoru no Nikusyokujyu – Contra Hard Corps
They’re Back – Streets Of Rage 4
Wave 131 – Streets Of Rage 2
Twilight Express – Battle Mania Daiginjou
Cammy’s Theme – Super Street Fighter 2
Laughing To The Bank – Chief Keef
Don’t Like – Chief Keef
Guile’s Theme – Super Street Fighter 2
Alien Power – Streets Of Rage 2
Mach Rider – Super Smash Bros. Melee
Evil Ryu’s Theme – Street Fighter Alpha 3
manyroses – GenesisKeys
Sugar Groove 2 – GenesisKeys
To Be Soaring – GenesisKeys
Brink Of Control – MarkeyJester
Theme Of Manus – GenesisKeys
deep+burial – GenesisKeys

Second Channel: @stristerdirectorscut
Discord link: https://discord.com/invite/Gnxp7me
Discord Tag: strister

Those Wacky Tags: #roadto3k #osonic​​​ #sonicthehedgehog​​​ #sega​​​ #sonicmovie​​​ #sonicfanart​​​ #sonicboom​​​ #sonamy​​​ #amyrose​​​ #art​​​ #memes​​​ #sonicmemes​​​ #sonicx​​​ #nintendo​​​ #sonicart​​​ #shadowthehedgehog​​​ #sonicmania​​​ #videogames​​​ #anime​​​ #sonicadventure​​​ #knucklestheechidna​​​ #sonicteam​​​ #tails​​​ #gaming​​​ #sonicthehedgehogmovie​​​ #tailsthefox​​​ #fanart​​​ #knuckles​​​ #silverthehedgehog​​​ #r​​​ #bhfyp #archiesonic #archie #sonicuniverse #KenPenders #KarlBollers #Ianflynn#tails #supersmashbros #sonicedit #sonicmemes #tailsthefox #sonicthehedgehogmovie #luigi #sonicmovie #sonicx #sonic #sonicthehedgehog #sega #sonicmovie #nintendo #sonicfanart #memes #art #amyrose #sonicmemes #sonicboom #shadowthehedgehog #videogames #sonicx #sonicadventure #sonicart #sonicmania #r #tails #sonamy #knuckles #sonicteam #knucklestheechidna #gaming #anime #tailsthefox #sonicthehedgehogmovie #hondasonic #fanart #mario #knowingsmile

Hope y’all have a Merry Christmas everyone, I am never doing another essay alone ever again 🗣️🎄‼️

source

17 thoughts on “The Mediocre Masterpiece Of IDW Sonic The Hedgehog: The 5 Year Retrospective (IDW Sonic Video Essay)”

  1. This is only my opinion, but this what I think. I never not liked the Metal Virus Arc, and it is one of my favorite stories, just because of it's dark tone and Sonic's existential crisis and conclusion. Scrapnik Island is probably my favorite miniseries in the franchise and I have enjoyed the supporting cast and world building, for my least favorite arc, I would say Test Run. I also don't view it as an adaption because it is now apart of the main story.

    Reply
  2. This book has always been “there” for me. I’m completely caught up, and there’s been nothing that’s happened in it’s 5-year run. I especially don’t like Sonic in this. Having Sonic be someone who gives thought to any of his actions be it they bring about serious consequences or him doubt himself and think about morality is completely out of character. Remember that is supposed to be the same Sonic as the games. A character who has never cared about reformation or even justice. There’s tons of other issues I have, like the restrictions keeping the creativity so low that nothing can happen, making this book feel like a waste of time

    Reply
  3. The only IDW Sonic content I’ve consumed is the Metal Virus Arc, I thought it was very good but now I realize it’s mostly because of the interesting Zombie Plot. I really don’t like how the characters themselves are written which sucks because now Ian Flynn is writing the Sonic Games and Frontiers has only furthered my disdain for his version of Sonic & Friends.

    Reply
  4. Also guys dont forget that most bad characterization of the characters are Sega's fault, they literally have a list of things that are obligatory to follow when dealing with certain characters

    Reply
  5. THANK YOU! I’ve BEEN saying that IDW Sonic is miserably OoC because he will say anything and everything that’ll make him sound morally correct, even if it contradicts something he previously said.

    He’s a motor mouth with none of the flair that made earlier iterations tick. There’s just no way that this is the same Sonic from Black Knight.

    Reply

Leave a Comment