On July 20, 2015, beloved 60-year-old chiropractor Mary Yoder falls violently ill and is rushed to the hospital. Two days later, she dies, leaving her family and friends in a state of stunned disbelief, in Season 15, Episode 2, “Poisonous Hearts.”
Stay up to date on all of A&E’s premieres at http://aetv.com/schedule.
#AmericanJustice
Subscribe for more from American Justice and other great A&E shows:
http://aetv.us/subscribe-ae
Find out more about the show and watch full episodes on our site:
https://www.aetv.com/shows
Check out exclusive A&E content:
Website – http://www.aetv.com/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AETV/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/aetv
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/aetv
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@aetv
A&E® leads the cultural conversation through high-quality, thought provoking original programming with a unique point of view. Whether it’s the network’s distinctive brand of award-winning disruptive reality or groundbreaking documentary, A&E makes entertainment an art form. Visit us at aetv.com for more info.
source
Stay up to date on all of A&E's premieres at aetv.com/schedule.
The defense attorneys… How do they sleep at night?
The detective pretending he had surveillance video of Kaitlyn purchasing the prepaid credit cards used to buy the poison led to a confession that she bought the prepaid cards. I think she's still maintaining her innocence but It's difficult for me to get pass this part. Kaitlyn's supporters are saying the incriminating info on Kaitlyn's phone was done by Adam using a hacking technique. I wonder if there are other experts that can corroborated or debunk that.
She's guilty. There must be something wrong with her to go to those lengths to get back at Adam. Horrible, senseless crime. She has no remorse. She didn't even seem upset that Mary was dead.
Her defense attorney needs Jesus. As does the minion.
Poor Adam. His mom is dead, his girlfriend is a sociopath and his dad is shtupping his dead wife's sister.
I feel for Adam, I suspect it will be a long time before he trusts another romantic interest.
She kicked the stamp?!? She deserves to get caught…. Dummy
Wow
Her attorney is delusional.
"No evidence?" There's a ton of evidence, and it ALL points to Kaitlyn.
Remember people. When you die, your spouse can easily end up with your sibling within weeks to pickup where you left off. Now that's love.
How can she stand there and say "I'm innocent"? The evidence proves she is not. However, I'm still asking what was her motive. Revenge against Adam seems so senseless. I'd have liked to hear more about her motive during deliberations if I were on the jury.
When Kaitlyn said poison was a lady's weapon, she probably read that during her research on how to commit this crime. She was just too dumb and couldn't keep her mouth shut. Not to mention she licked the stamp. I thought self adhesive stamps had replaced self lick stamps long before this crime. Most envelopes are self adhesive too, but DNA on it wasn't mentioned.
I live here and the trial hasnt even started yet! It was just on the local news yet again the other day. And hth did they get such clean shots of downtown??? It's a mess down there, garbage and crows everywhere!!!!
That was a long and rambling note to the police… written by a woman obviously. Katelyn and Patricia Ramsey are both Evil Women who destroy lives.
Wake up buddy
The jury got it right. This young woman has issues and would probably always be a danger to anyone she would get close to.
The fact that the defense attorney couldn't build a substantial case to refute the prosecutors argument that Kaitlyn did it is proof of guilt. The prosecutors job is to provide evidence of guilt, and the defense is supposed to provide reasonable doubt and they couldn't do that. I feel sorry for the attorney that's so staunchly protecting her in the face of so much evidence and has none of his own to truly prove she didn't do it.
That's not what salt of the earth means
That defense attorney reminds me of a worm
There was no motive. Should have been reasonable doubt. Jury got this one wrong. The husband did it.
defense attorney: our circumstantial evidence is stronger than the states..
sooo, is that like being a little bit pregnant? a woman is either pregnant or she's not.. on the other hand if it quacks and walks like a duck, it's a duck! circumstances can be a flashing neon sign.. denial doesn't change the circumstances.. and even if there's a bulb or 2 or a few out in the sign, it can still be read.
Cannot fathom this defense attorney’s thought process.
I'm a disabIed RN. I promise you no one would commit suicide by Colchicine poisoning. It's a brutal, miserable way to die.
I'm onIy a few minutes into it, but women are poisoners, I will truly be surprised if the kiIIer is a man.
It's truIy a horrible way to go. Someone wanted her to suffer.
RIP ❤prayers to her famiIy.
Her defense attorney might’ve been crazier than her 🤦🏾♂️
Cateylyn knows she killed the woman, she wanted to hurt Adam by hurting his mom.
Interesting story
When she put emphasis on her being a WHITE lady.
Nice looking murderer
Man, that car is a mess.
I was rather surprised to find out that they left out much of the story here. You know who agrees with Katie Conley and her lawyer? Mary's sisters! Mary had four sisters. One of them is with Bill Yoder. All the others defend Katie and blame both Bill and his son Adam.
She isn’t innocent. It’s clear as day and night. She obviously guilty. That defense attorney is so lost 😂
She says she is innocent, BUT how does she explain… The DNA on the poison bottle? How does she explain the poison company saying they talked with a young woman when she ordered the poison? Also, she knew exactly where the poison was in his car. She is guilty!! 🙄🤔🤦🏼♀
The defense attorney's are suppose to do their job but her first attorney is lying to himself believing she is innocent… Evidence was damning.
How can it be manslaughter in the first degree? Like, how is that even possible? Manslaughter means it wasn't planned. First degree means it was planned.
I have this inexplicable urge to buy Allstate Insurance after listening to this.
May Kaitin the sociopath be rotting in jail…..sentence was 30 years TOO short.
Wow is this my brother's ex wife.
if you get violently ill and you haven't eaten taco bell lately just assume someone is poisoning you
Isn't Colchicine available only by prescription? Wouldn't she need a DEA# to purchase it? How was it paid for? Couldn't the method of purchase be traced back to her/
I thought the double jeopardy rule meant that you can’t convict someone of the same thing twice…