HoI4: The Great War Redux – The "Superior" French State (Part 2)



The “Great War Redux” mod takes us back to World War 1, where we’ve taken control of a divided French republic. With a little bit …

source

44 thoughts on “HoI4: The Great War Redux – The "Superior" French State (Part 2)”

  1. Just on the naval supremacy point, there were more players, but it was still very one-sided. Britain maintained the 2-power standard doctrine until 1921 and this meant that they had a larger fleet than the next two powers combined (France and Russia historically). Russia's fleet was effectively annihilated in the Russo-Japanese War of 1904-5 from which it didn't really recover. In the 1910s as Germany built up their High Seas Fleet, the Royal Navy settled for whatever Germany had plus 60%. This was unsustainable for the German (!) economy, which tells you just how powerful Britain was in the run-up to WW1. France had a set of conflicting doctrines which meant their procurement was slow and ineffective.

    When the Dreadnought was commisioned in 1906, this effectively reset the numbers, but it was still no contest. Britain was unrivaled at sea and the US and Japan were relatively-speaking colonial backwaters until well into the 1910s. The US could only afford two dreadnoughts a year and almost no escorts (due to Congressional budget bickering). Until the end of the war and the Washington Treaty, no one else really had a chance. If you think the base HOI4 British deathstack is bad, that's nothing on what the force ratio was historically in WW1.

    Obviously the AI in HOI4 is dumb, so there are ways round it, but historically the French gave up any chance of outcompeting Britain navally, and the US only exceeded the Royal Navy's fleetsize in 1942.

    </history_lecture>

    Reply
  2. 24:00 "why bother just doesn't make a lot of sense you know it's like it's it's like algebra you know you put in the y because it stands for why do we care" best quote i heard this week

    Reply
  3. Hey Pravus, just wanting to let you know that in your description you put, "No copyright infringement intended. Europa Universalis 4 copyright is owned…" I just wanted you to know so you don't get into trouble cause I enjoy your content and your the reason I actually got back in to Hearts of Iron IV.

    Reply
  4. The point of the gun reliability law was that all guns produced in that time have plus 10 percent reliability (this also doesn't make a new type of gun so it applies to all previously made guns)

    Reply
  5. I'm sure someone already highlighted this but it could be argued one of the main reasons the empires went to war in 1914 was the naval arms race between the UK and Germany. Tension had been mounting between the two states as a race to build battleships increased which is one of the reasons we see the London Naval treaty. Effectively though the British fleet would dominate and blockade Germany.

    Reply
  6. As long as you don't have any skulls on your cap, mug or socks, I'm pretty sure you aren't one of the baddies.
    When traveling down the Rhine make sure to not succumb to Lorelai. Your wife probably won't approve and I've heard that drowning isn't fun.
    If you have the time I'd suggest exploring some of the tributary rivers like the Main, Neckar and Mosel.

    Reply
  7. The reason close air support isn't an option in the game im sure is because the idea of it wasn't really a thing at this point. I think most countries started to realize it toward the end of the war, around 1917, not entirely sure on that. Still, close air support is extremely dangerous if you can't communicate effectively, so even if the idea was put in practice, it would likely be done so very rarely.

    I'm pretty sure this is right, but I'm sure if anything is wrong someone here will correct me

    Reply
  8. I just like to see how pravus is clearly struggling, on one hand the focus tree gives some powerfull stuff but on the other hand monitization and imoral things…
    I guess imperialism wins after all xD

    Reply
  9. Maybe a bit late for the comment, but the Bonnot Gang was a small phenomena of Illegalism, a branch of anarchism that supported insurrection by illegal means, for example bank robberies, arson, theft, etc. The Gang was notorious for the use of modern day cars, guns and speed on their operations. They were surrounded and defeated later. It's nominal leader, Jules Bonnot, died during a gun fight with the police. One of their surviving members, Victor Serge, became part of the bolsheviks and later an allie of Trotsky. Small world.

    Reply
  10. The Xinhai Revolution was a revolution in 1911 let by Sun-yat-sen against Yuen Shikai, Puyi and the rest of the Great Qing government. Minzu, Minquan and Minsheng stands for Democracy, Civil Power, and Livelihood in Putonghua/ Mandarin.

    Reply
  11. I am a week late for this, but anyway. I just wanted to comment on the "rediscovery" of Machu Picchu at 06:40. The ruins weren't a secret to the local population. There were even people living among the ruins doing farming. At least that is what I remember from the guided tour I took there in 2015.

    Reply

Leave a Comment