Birthday by Red Velvet was… weird



Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXho5ljLhsVJDfB-e3aMfog/join

Read This!

Fancam Credits:

Irene: https://youtu.be/6Cav50Eaxso
Seulgi: https://youtu.be/udqle-2K7vg
Joy: https://youtu.be/qqmKrSPl4b8
Wendy: https://youtu.be/NBmCrW3sXnA
Yeri: https://youtu.be/uIrLdnNXGW4

https://dotherightthing.carrd.co/

Intro Song: Crush by MCND
Outro Song: Cat Waltz by MCND

https://planetminjae.carrd.co/

Business Inquiries: [email protected]

FAQ:

Name: Juice

Pronouns: He/Him

Tags:
Irene Seulgi Wendy Joy Yeri Happiness Be Natural Automatic Ice Cream Cake Dumb Dumb ICC Wish Tree One of These Nights Rookie Russian Roulette Would U Red Flavor Rebirth Peek a boo Peek-a-Boo Bad Boy Power Up RBB Really Bad Boy Zimzalabim Umpah Umpah Psycho Queendom Feel My Rhythm FMR Birthday Cookie Jar Sappy Sayonara Wildside Sunny Side Up Kingdom Come Pose Naughty Monster Hello Like Water 28 Reasons Solo Subunit Stage Performance review K-Pop kpop k pop idol SM Entertainment reaction big 3 3rd gen the ReVe festival 2022 bye bye on a ride zoom celebrate blackpink twice aespa snsd girls generation f(x) fx nct exo wayv nct 127 nct u nct dream birthday album red velvet comeback

#kpop #redvelvet #birthday #rv #레드벨벳

00:00 Intro
01:08 Birthday
05:48 Bye Bye
06:46 On A Ride
07:44 ZOOM
08:27 Celebrate
09:16 Overall

source

24 thoughts on “Birthday by Red Velvet was… weird”

  1. I love how they stick to their concept and the visuals are great but the title track is just unlistenable for me where I’ve liked other title tracks from the past… I’m interested in the bsides tho

    Reply
  2. To be honest, I love your opinion about this song and about red velvet. I really appreciate everyone's thought about my favorite group, red velvet. And yeah, for me "birthday" is not a very challenging title song from red velvet, it is too easy for them. I don't know why SM lowered their standard on my babies when they can do something harder and more challenging? I'm still trying to understand how SM treat Red Velvet

    Reply
  3. For me, On a ride sounds really similar to bella poarches build a bitxh, like the first time I heard on a ride build a bitxh instantly came into my mind, maybe thats why it sounds familiar?

    Reply
  4. I really personally liked Birthday, is so Red Velvet but different at the same time, and I agree with it missing like a vocally charged bridge, it would've elevated the song a lot, that's the only thing I would change, but it's ok since i really enjoyed it as a whole, overall is one of my favourite comebacks this year

    EDIT: Btw, there's a part of On a Ride that reminds me of Ariana Grande's 34+35, ikd if I'm the only one, but anyway I love it, one of my favourites in the album as well

    Reply
  5. Red velvet 2022 is a repeat of red velvet 2018
    Feel my rhythm was the start of a style that stuck with the public, sm then copied that style and did it again with birthday, the sampling of classical music is the niche of it,

    Bad boy was a song that worked with red velvet and with the public, was repeated with rbb, the niche sm worked with was the heavily westernized sonics

    And i like that, 2022 is just the perfected version of 2018,with better cohesion between the two albums, sm knows what makes RV palatable to the public yet still being unique

    Reply

Leave a Comment