The crew rank all the new cards from the Commander Masters precons starting with Eldrazi Unbound and Enduring Enchantments!
Today’s show is brought to you by Card Conduit! Get 10% off your order and support our show by using our link https://www.cardconduit.com/mtggoldfish
Follow us on your favorite podcast app!
▲ Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4LviEgd…
▲ iTunes: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast…
▲ Google Podcasts: https://podcasts.google.com/?feed=aHR…
Buy our merch! Clear out Richard’s garage! https://mtggoldfishmerch.com/
source
You can find the tier lists here:
Eldrazi: https://tiermaker.com/create/commander-masters-eldrazi-unbound-preconstructed-deck-15985900
Enchantments: https://tiermaker.com/create/commander-masters-enduring-enchantments-preconstructed-deck-15985900
Ghoulish Impetus is probably my favourite card from the enchantments deck, and I feel like it's being underrated. I'm gonna be trying it in every deck I have with black.
Skittering Cicada also does not die to artifact wipes. But I agree with Tomer a bit and I am glad Seth mentioned how colourless decks can work. As a colourless player, I tend to get quite a bit of attention from my opponents.
Poor Tomer, I just imagine him screaming at his screen as he edited this haha. Still great episode, always love all the spicy takes even if I don't agree with them.
I appreciate Tomers extra comments and input, but it does mean i need to watch the episode rather than listen to it like a podcast.
He could almost do a react video
Anikthea is reverse Myrkul
If you turn the audio off this video is actually less annoying and more informative.
You should watch the Command Zone with the commmander masters decks. Jimmy gets his commmander out turn 2. (Eldrazi Cascade)
Wow….that was really hard to watch…!
I almost stopped watching during the colorless card analysis, lol. I wish Tomer could have been here for this one as well. Someone needed to do a better job reminding Richard and Phil what the context of these cards are. Like if you don't want to play a colorless deck because you think they're bad, that's fine, but as someone else in the comments said, you do not curve out in a colorless deck. There just seems to be a fundamental misunderstanding of how colorless decks work.
I think the real thing that bothers me is that I felt like in this episode, Richard and Phil kept saying "no, cut it" but didn't really offer any actual alternatives. It's easy to look at a card and say it's bad, but can you find a replacement for it? Like you're not replacing Darksteel Monolith with Thran Dynamo because you're playing both in this deck. In a colorless deck, there are not a ton of cards that do what Desecrate Reality does.
This isn't an argument for or against colorless decks, I just want to comment that I think a lot of this analysis of the colorless cards in this episode is poor given that these cards are meant for a colorless Eldrazi deck. There are very few, if any, of these cards that would EVER be played outside of a colorless deck, but that's not what the analysis was supposed to be of (based on what they said at the beginning of the episode)
Please Tomer, next time a Commander set goes around you need to be in the video! These takes…they hurt my soul.
Ugin's Mastery is stealth Morph support, as playing the creature face down gives you the free one, and then you turn them face up, either the one you play or the ones you pick off the top. And it goes in any Morph deck!
I lpve all the Tomer edits because he's always right
This is a good podcast because it's the first time I've ever snap-agreed with Tomer on literally everything lmao.
Why is there text covering the entire screen? WTF is this editing? lol
Tomer is adding all my comments. We need some artifact/eldrazi decks on commander clash, this is bad for rating.
if you ramped out zuludok on turn 2 (jeweled lotus+solring, mana crypt, rocks make it fairly consistant turn 2 if you wanted) its not going to work with casting a 7 drop on 3. If you aren't playing Mana crypt/solring and getting this out turn 3 (4 at the latest) its gonna be real late in the game and getting hit by sweepers and removal since opponents just had 3-4 turns to draw cards while you just ramped and you're going to be pulling a lot of chaff from the cascades
I'm siding with Tomer…I preordered the colorless precon and it's IMO GAS! No respect for this colorless deck!
We need a colorless commander episode lol
abstruce archaic –> target the promised ones ability upon entry –> take over 2 players entire turns? void gorger cut tier? WTF?! idk about these opinions dude lol
Without crim and tomer those evaluations are insane: crim and tomer tend to evaluate decks for casual play. Seth has good ideas but changes his mind very easly.
Calamity of the Titans is an include to any Eldrazi deck, despite how bad Richard thinks the card is. We have to remember that Eldrazi decks can't really output a lot of creatures up to defend themselves during early > midgame to preserve their life totals. Your only real defense against early aggression are board wipes. Ugin, Nev's Disk, All is Dust, and Rachet Bombs are all good board wipes, but in a 100 card singleton deck, the chances of you drawing into these cards are slim, especially in a colorless deck where there are close to zero tutors.
i currently have a very very strong kairi and hidetsugu(uWu) commander deck and rise of the eldrazi will be so busted in there.
so sad about seth being outvoted for everything eldrazi phil and richard need to play some more colorless decks
I think y'all overrated almost every single enchantress card. The only cards you wanted enchantress deck are enchantresses or actual enchantments
Everyone is focused on the abysmal colorless takes that i feel everyone is sleeping on their terrible takes on the Impetus cards. When Richard said "if the creature is big enough to matter then it's already attacking" i wanted to scream "but it's not attacking you!" Those cards are great because they make friends while eliminating threats to you, especially at mid power tables
*we're gonna rate these cards in the context of their decks.
*immediately compares colorless cards to colored cards
Lmao dont ever change mtggoldfish 😂
Omarthis: There's no existing archetype for it to go into and you would have to create something for it so it's bad.
Narci: There's no existing archetype for it to go into and you would have to create something for it so it's interesting and good actually.
Guys your bias is showing.
Omarthis is weird because if you manifest a modular creature and turn it face up it doesn't get counters.
Richard routinely has the worst takes on cards. I guess I should be surprised by this since he thinks Cartographer's Hawk and Secret Rendezvous are good cards……
Seth: Isn't this colorless card good in colorless?
Richard and Phil: Eh it doesn't also make me a martini and valet park my car so it's garbage.
"Does the deck need an extra turn?" Are you high Richard? Yes, yes it wants an extra turn.
Tomer gotta be there or shush man 😂 or give your notes beforehand idk the notes on screen break the conversation imo so I just listened to this episode as podcast instead of watching with tomer rants on screen
Tomer needs to bring an eldrazi deck soon
I really want to try ugin's mastery in my kadena deck
Curses are auras
Darksteel monolith is trash but Demon of Fate's Design is insane? Not sure about that
As someone that loves Goad, and thus the Impetus cards, this version that comes back after the card dies is amazing
Tomer being the most reasonable even when he is gone lol.
Omarthis is also a random combo with Celestial Kirin to nuke all the the lands so it's definitely going in that 99.
Richard is hilarious today, took some funny juice?
the colorless discussions just show how badly the pod needs tomer
Ondu spirit dancer at c is an insane take. I feel like some of these people shouldn’t be giving opinions on magic with who wrong they are.
i think this needs to be done again with Phil and Richard replaced, their takes were garbage on the colorless cards.