Before anything else, the “line” in this video refers to the amount of time that a member of a group has to sing or rap in a specific song. When it comes to the true relevance of line distribution in K-Pop and whether it needs to be equal or not, it has been a matter of discussion by multiple K-pop fans all over the globe, but primarily heated disagreement. Most of the time, the higher the duration one will sing or rap, the more chance that member will shine in that particular song as they will be able to showcase their capabilities. Presumably, the lines can be distributed based on their skills and how fitting the members’ voices are to the genre and concept of the song. Therefore, it is truly inevitable in a group to have a member with the most and least lines. This video would then provide insights to the viewers regarding the specified topic. The question here would be, “does that member really deserves to have that many/little amounts of lines?”
Disclaimer:
-only Korean title tracks were counted
-This video does not, in any form, promote fanwars. This is for entertainment only.
Disclaimer: We do not own the videos, music, and pictures used. No copyright infringement intended. All rights reserved to the original owner. Please send us a message at [email protected] if you want this to be taken down. Thank you so much.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
Connect, ask, or request videos on our:
Instagram
kristinakylacristobal
kyle.cristobal_
Let’s be friends on Facebook!
Edmond Kyle Cristobal
Kristina Kyla Cristobal
Don’t forget to like, share, subscribe, and tap the notification bell to see more videos like this.
Thank you so much for watching!
source
I apologize for disremembering Enhypen's Blessed-Cursed. But anyway, the members who got the least and most lines are still the same. Ni-ki with 77 seconds instead of 61 and Heeseung with 149 seconds instead of 127. Thank you.
These fancam are so stunning
Jinni is not a former member for me she's always from nmixx 😭😭😭😭 I can't believe it I can't accept it 😥😥
why do people say that itzy has fair ld when literally their MAIN rapper gets less lines than the sub vocal & rapper…. like wtf? and how does a lead vocal get more lines than a main vocal? this isn’t fair line distribution. jyp should either change their positions or the line distribution because this isn’t fair at all.
same situation with aespa btw. but aespa is at least a clearly vocal based group, but still I can’t understand why a main rapper gets less lines than the lead rapper and the lead vocal tops the main vocal.
THE ATEEZ ONE MAKES ME CRY AND LAUGH AT THE SAME TIME
Yes Jongho is the main vocalist and the best vocalist but damn 500 seconds compared to not even 150 poor Yeosang
150 seconds isn't the length of basically any song by Ateez so if Yeosang put all his lines in a song it STILL would be too short for their discography
How can you live with 2 SECONDS in a song?!?!
Meanwhile Jongho's total lines are almost 10 minutes – that's maybe 3 whole songs?!
I CAN'T KQ WHAT ARE YOU DOING NOT EVERYONE SHOULD GET THE SAME LINES BUT IT CAN'T BE LIKE THIS COME ON
That guy in ateez is crazy cause 13 sec being your most (Bahiyyih most is also 13 and she has it twice) but to have that many songs and still-
No way Felix has the least lines-
He must be an icon maker cause his verses get played the most i swear
Just looking at "former" and getting so sad TT
straykids?
Gidle??
What is happening
Honestly the IVE one makes me laugh
still don't understand why wonyoung has more lines than liz
Le sserafim
Least – sakura
Most – yunjin
Nmixx
Least – bae
Most – kyujin
loona 🙁
Ateez kinda makes me cry and smile at the same time. They really treat Jongho according to his position as a main vocalist, literally giving him what a main vocalist should be doing. But kinda sad for Yeosang. I hope he's going to have more lines in HALAZIA
Yknow, just in case anyone wants to start something about (G)I-DLE's line distribution I really do want to remind you that their songs exist all thanks to Soyeon, she deserves her lines
WAIT WAS THAT 3 SECONDS FOR AN 8 MEMBER TEAM? WHAT
haewon is a main vocalist, that’s crazy that she’s LAST
Damn the difference between yeosang and jungho is 381 seconds.
Hyungseo has a really lovely voice but she doesn't get many lines, is sad
why did i think beomgyu would be the one with the least lines? so this whole time moas have been screaming about mistreatment but he's actually not the one with the least lines after all? is this for real?
Loona should of been in this video, then we would of seen Haseul getting 1.5s of lines, and Vivi getting 2.6 seconds 😐
What’s the intro song?
you forgot hurt by newjeans
I thought E:U and Onda from least line than other member
Thank you for put Iz*one here🥺
Nmixx has more songs
i think han has the most lines is because he raps and sings in them
Doyoung voice is so good
I hope they utilises it more
Also give my boy center parts too
NI-KI doesn't get a fair treatment and this has been the case since his debut. This year was the worst!
Izone wow
It always makes me laugh when the main dancer has more than the main vocal cough kep1er cough
Or when a sub vocalist has more than the main vocalist cough ive *cough
Or when a main vocalist has the least cough nmixx cough
Wonnie’s is not even that much. People kinda overreact. Compared to other groups it’s not even much of a gap
Kep1er and Ive Being the only girl groups where Main and lead vocals don't sing most of the lines, I find it interesting
imagine having a cute voice like hitomi's in your group and only giving her 8 seconds of a 3 minute long song 🤧
Ive's line distribution is messed up as heck
if you really want to know how good or bad the difference is you should subtract the number of seconds the person with the least lines got from the person with the most lines and divide by the number of title tracks.
for example: yeji got 295 seconds. subtract that from ryujin's 199 and you get 94. divide by the number of title tracks, which is 8, and the average difference is 11.75 seconds.
in my opinion –
the average difference is less than 5 seconds: exceptional
5-10: amazing
10-12: great
12-15: good
15-17: meh
18-20: bad
20-25: terrible
25+: exceptionally bad
just want to say that this is quite a flawed system, yet i still think it's pretty good
How about fromis_9??
The ratio between the most and least lines in each group (the closer to 1 the "fairer" the line distribution)
Aisha/Mia: 0.338
Ryujin/Yeji: 0.674
Huening Kai-Soobin/Taehyun: 0.691
Niki/Heeseung: 0.517
Minji/Hyein: 0.672
Hyeonseo/Chaewon: 0.484
Umji/Eunha: 0.692
Yeosang/Jongho: 0.273
Juhaknyeon/Hyunjae: 0.416 (since Eric was on hiatus in Whisper era)
Giselle/Winter: 0.592
Seeun/Sieun: 0.5
Gaeul/Wonyoung: 0.452
Eunchae/Yunjin: 0.333
Doyoung/Jeongwoo: 0.404
Bahiyyih/Dayeon: 0.493
Jinni/Lily: 0.579
Shuhua/Soyeon: 0.422
Tsuki/Haram: 0.614 (since Sheon was added later to the group)
Hyunjin-Felix/Han: 0.549
Hitomi-Hyewon/Yuri: 0.331
Per these numbers, the "fairer" ones are TXT, Itzy, New Jeans, Viviz and Billlie and the opposite being Ateez, Lesserafim, Everglow and Izone
NI-KIくんのパートが少ないのは悲しいけど、一番チッケム再生数が多いのは凄いことですよね。
ニキくんの低音のボーカルは、魅力的で大好きです。最近はボーカルもラップも上達してきたのでこれからパートが増えることを期待します。
I’m shocked it isn’t Jaehyuk for treasure
i think skz got the fairest line tho bcs even hyunjin and felix got the least lines, they got all the killing parts! and for han, he became the member to have the most lines bcs he got to rap and sing as well
Fact most of lest line idol in the group aren't the lest popular and some of are the most popular member in the group special jyp idols
Can someone tell me name of all idols in thumbnail
Yeosang's total time makes me wanna cry, it's unfair to him 🙁
Of course jeongwoo is the main vocalist next to yedam