Check out the full 50 min reaction on Patreon ▶▶ https://www.patreon.com/luscent
Insta ▶ ▶ bit.ly/luscentinsta
TikTok ▶ ▶ http://bit.ly/38wjKpw
Stream my music here! ▶▶ https://linktr.ee/Luscent
Personal Insta ▶ ▶ https://bit.ly/2CLshHC
00:00 Intro
01:24 Slut!
08:22 Say Don’t Go
13:27 Now That We Don’t Go
17:28 Suburban Legends
21:40 Is It Over Now?
26:37 Overall Thoughts
28:01 The BEST song is…
#1989taylorsversion #1989 #taylorswift
source
love your interpretation of now that we dont talk
1. Is It Over Now?
2. Now That We Don’t Talk
3. “Slut!”
4. Say Don’t Go
5. Suburban Legends
Really love these tracks, a lot of people say they give Midnights vibes but these feel so 1989 to me. In fact, I think many of them fit the 80's vibe more than standard tracks. That said, my ranking is:
1. Now That we don't talk (crime it is so short)
2. Say Don't Go
3. Is It over now?
4. Slut!
5. Suburban Legends
I really enjoyed this rerecord. Other than Fearless, this is the TS album I really gravitated towards on initial release so have stronger feelings than I did with Red/Speak Now – it felt like Taylor reclaimed this album for her but for us as well. I think this is the best rerecord personally and people will agree once they get over some of the subtle changes.
Great reaction!! My ranking would be:
1) Say Don't Go
2) Now That We Don't Talk
3) Slut!
4) Is It Over Now?
5) Suburban Legends
All of these vaults were so good! I wish Now That We Don't Talk was longer, but I also like that it's short and to the point and kind of just feels like an interlude!
Also just as a lore fill in, all of these songs are very much a comment on hers and Harry Styles relationship and the criticism that she got from his fans at the time! She refers to very specific moments of their relationship in all of the songs! 🤗
i think is it over now (which is definitely my favorite of the vault tracks!) is about a relationship that ended on really uncertain terms and both of them keep trying to move on with new people but realize they keep missing each other and searching for one another in new relationships. and maybe she’s even realizing that she’s jealous of his new partners and thinking like if i still care so much and both of us are still searching for a way to get back at each other then clearly we’re both still hung up on this so is it even actually over
Ranking for now…
1. Say Don't Go
2. Is It Over Now?
3. "Slut!"
4. Suburban Legends
5. Now That We Don't Talk
Everyone’s has their own interpretations and they are valid ❤ I personally think all the vault songs are about her short relationship with Harry. I think the line in Now that we don’t talk that says “it’s not platonic it’s just ended” leads me to a romantic relationship. In is it over now I think their relationship was very on again off again and she is talking about the “off times” questioning “is it actually really over or will we go back together”
But the great thing is Taylor write songs that are relatable in so many different ways that people can have them fit the situation they want 💙
1: Is it over now?
2: Now that we don't talk
3: Say don't go
4: Suburban Legends
5: Slut!
my ranking:
1. is it over now?
2. now that we don't talk
3. slut!
4. suburban legends
5. say don't go
Now that we don't talk is probably not about a friend. I'd like to say it's about HS
I have to say my predictions were spot on. I keep going back and forth between Slut! and Is it over now? As my favorite.
1. Is it over now?
2. Say don't go
3. "Slut!"
4. Now that we don't talk
5. Suburban legends
the jumping off of very tall somethings line is so dramatic yet also concerning i love her
Is it over now & say don’t Go – i can’t decide which i love more / $lut! Follows suit – its so soft just as you said / by ranking now that we don’t talk „only“ third most favourite almost feels like unfair, cause it contains so much emotion that resonated inside myself served with those lyrics –
Least loved is suburban legends.. just because didnt hit me personal as hard as its sisters
Thank you so much for another very thoughtfull reaction
here’s my vault track ranking!!
1. say don’t go
2. is it over now?
3. suburban legends
4. “slut!”
5. now that we don’t talk
My ratings:
1. Suburban Legends
2. Say Don't Go
3. Slut!
4. Is It Over Now
5. Now that we don't talk
I feel like my ranking is just opposite urs!
1. Is it over now
2. Say don’t go
3. Suburban legends
4. Slut!
5. Now that we don’t talk
i think is it over now is talking about a relationship that was not exclusive and basically over (re: style “i heard that you’ve been out and about with some other girl”) so I don’t think either of them were cheating necessarily, but they were both with other people too. also has references to the out of the woods bridge lyrically “when you lost control, red blood, white snow”
after a couple days of listening my ranking is
1. is it over now?
2. slut!
3. say don’t go
4. now that we don’t talk
5. suburban legends. this one is the only one i’m not really vibing with yet but it’s alright.
My Ranking:
1) Say Don't Go
2) Is it Over Now?
3) Slut!
4) Suburban Legends
5) Now That We Don't Talk
1. Say don’t go
2. Now that we don’t talk
3. Slut!
4. Is it over now?
5. Suburban Legends
depressing when they don’t listen to the entire album