Has Star Wars' Relentless Retconning Hurt Its Legacy? | CineFix Top 100



We head to a galaxy far far away to discuss a little space opera that changed the way we make movies, talk about movies, and build franchises out of those movies. George Lucas’ Star Wars stormed onto the scene in 1977 and was relentlessly retconned as they moved to franchise the biggest original IP of all time. Star Wars is inescapable now, but Clint, Cal and Alex try to dissect the movie it was while also keeping in mind all the tinkering, changes, sequels and spinoffs that have followed. How do you talk about a movie that has been discussed, analyzed, and iterated on for nearly fifty years? As a film that has bled into every part of our subconscious, right down to the sound design, is it possible that this doesn’t crack the top 10?
Meanwhile, Dan’s algorithm is busy trying to stamp out the pesky panel rebellions against its absolute power over the list…
CineFix Top 100 is produced by Tayo Oyekan, with Director of Photography, Jamie Parslow and Technical Producer, Marhyan Franzen. Our Executive Producers are Clint Gage, Dan Parkhurst and Corrado Caretto. Logo and graphic design by Eric Sapp and title animations by Casey Redmon.
CineFix Top 100 is available on all your podcast networks including:
Spotify https://open.spotify.com/show/02lznfKZ2gCnBwFoTgKlYr
Apple Podcasts https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/cinefix-top-100/id1693413490
Amazon Music https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/80256cff-2174-4d69-a9c7-8b565e96e39b
Be sure to subscribe to CineFix for more movie lists, brilliant moments and top 100!
97. Groundhog Day Doesn’t Need to Explain Itself | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_l8H2r5wLPM
84. Independence Day is a Goddamn Masterpiece | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xY-9wBcAXmU
83. Who Framed Roger Rabbit is Lamp-Bumping Perfection | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pcT6Kyo1gQI
71. Parasite is Genre-Bending Social Satire At Its Most Metaphorical | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MhlqplJOzIM
66. The Three Amigos – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DJEgqedUW9E
63. Raiders of the Lost Ark Was Spielberg Shooting From The Hip | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ly5Mxq9qcmM
56. Sunset Boulevard is STILL a Crazy, Meta Middle Finger to Hollywood | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykjfQgN9gd8
53. Orson Welles Created The ‘Star Role’ in The Third Man | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=In2tp8HoLh0
49. City of God is Eloquent Violence | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DG43jOFSHSg
42. The Exorcist Is Still Scary Thanks To Classic Film Trickery | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSpN-409FVA
28. Seven Samurai: Is There a More Influential Action Film? | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rDhqmm2Yes
22. RoboCop Features Cinema’s Smartest Shootout in a Cocaine Factory https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kT71d1WrAnc
??. Terminator 2: Judgment Day Is The Most Perfect Action Movie of All Time | CineFix Top 100 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6AJTY8LjKQ

source

43 thoughts on “Has Star Wars' Relentless Retconning Hurt Its Legacy? | CineFix Top 100”

  1. Opinion; The pre-existing IP/sequel/reboot problem in Hollywood isn't because of Star Wars or any other franchise. It's because the people making decisions about what gets made DO NOT KNOW what makes a movie successful.

    Reply
  2. Star Wars, the original, has become a “Homework Movie,” more recognized as important than it is enjoyable. The endlesss retcons are bad enough but it’s the marketing to the point of incest that’s nauseating. Bed sheets, maybe, but spatulas? Waffle makers? Steering wheel covers?

    It turns me off. I imagine if Star Wars had been a solid hit, not a smash, it would have been a good experience for the rest of the trilogy and we’d all be happy. But it didn’t play out that way and the incels took over and made it racial and political.

    Reply
  3. I started watching this, but after about 90 seconds I realized… You guys wasted 87 minutes of your life (plus however long it took you to prepare it to upload,) and I wasn’t going to waste 87 minutes of MY life watching it.

    You see, art is subjective, something I assume you know. Therefore, the legacy of any artwork is also subjective.

    Said another way: No matter how many people love Star Wars, there’s plenty of people who don’t care about it, or actively hate it, and so for them, Star Wars has no legacy.

    And this will continue for as long as Star Wars is “remembered”. None of it matters.

    Reply
  4. 1977 Lucky Lady starring Gene Hackman and Burt Reynolds was supposed to be the big movie of the summer It also starred Liza Minnelli. Three of the biggest stars on the planet in a 1930s Prohibition romp. Star Wars was booked for only two weeks in theaters and set tobe pulled to make way for Lucky Lady.

    Reply
  5. Star Wars A New Hope was the very first Movie Movie. Almost every frame is a sort of reference to another classic movie. The twin sunset scene is directly lifted from John Ford's The searchers. The whole trench battle was created using cut together reerence footage from The Dam Busters and Squadron 633. Lucas was a classic movie geek.

    Reply
  6. Star Wars opened on a Friday in 1977; I saw it the next day. As a 14-year-old, I got every bit of information I could about it. From what I read, Lucas did not have a plan for more movies until after it became a success. The Empire Strikes Back improved on the orginal. Return of the Jedi was originally called Revenge of the Jedi, but that got neutered down just like the movie and Darth Vader. The final nail in the coffin for the franchise when I saw Anakin's ghost with Obi-wan at the end of that movie. The Star Wars universe for me is just the first 2 movies, and with Han Solo shooting first.

    Reply
  7. *Eisley…

    Only made it 00:33 seconds without proving that you're FAKE FANS who don't know ANYTHING about the Star Wars universe that umm Disney ruined and women last jedi woke jar jar CGI senate

    Honestly, it's the awful incel loser fans, who are a tiny but ferociously vocal minority (ironically) were awful in 1997 and awful in 1999 and awful ever since whenever literally anything happens at all, who have ruined its legacy and watered down its value as a universe. Most SW fan communities are amazing wholesome places, as is Celebration and other events, then there's just this cancer living under the surface trying to actively destroy the thing they claim to love. Horrid.

    Reply
  8. So season 2 has had SEVEN samurai, THREE amigos, star wars episode FOUR…

    Im calling it now: Next episode is going to be TWO fast 2 furious.

    The theme is numbers in the title. ive figured it out

    Reply
  9. Before I have seen Star Wars the first time, I have been cutting out the pictures of magazines, newspapers and TV guides for some time. It looked so interesting and spectacular to me! I was surprised to learn Han Solo wasn't the main hero. 😲

    Reply

Leave a Comment